BokingOne vs FIALAME vs JOYIN vs CANDLE IDEA vs Dofash: Spooky or just flimsy?

Halloween decorations5 products

Quick verdict

Don't get spooked by cheap gear

If you want something reliable, the FIALAME swinging ghost is the sturdiest option, while the CANDLE IDEA set offers the most festive variety. Avoid the fragile single-ghost options if you live where the wind actually blows.

Side by side

FeaturePhoto of BokingOne Ghost SetBokingOne Ghost SetPhoto of FIALAME Swinging GhostFIALAME Swinging GhostPhoto of JOYIN Hanging GhostJOYIN Hanging GhostPhoto of CANDLE IDEA Witch HatsCANDLE IDEA Witch HatsPhoto of Dofash Glowing GhostsDofash Glowing Ghosts
PriceCA$17.99CA$28.25CA$29.99CA$30.99CA$49.99
DurabilityThe FIALAME uses metal and heavy-duty fabric that actually stands a chance against a gust of wind.Fragile polyesterHeavy-duty fabric and metal (winner)Plastic and fabricDurable plasticOxford cloth
Lighting ModesThe CANDLE IDEA set gives you the most control for creating a flashy display.3 modes8 modesConstant/Timer8 modes (winner)8 modes
Ease of InstallationThe Dofash set is the easiest to string up across a wide space without getting into a mess.Simple hangingModerate assemblyEasy hangingRequires assemblySimple hanging (winner)

Product by product

BokingOne Ghost Set

Budget-conscious quick decor

A decent budget pick for a light touch. Just don't expect them to survive a real storm.

What We Liked 👍

  • Very affordable price
  • Compact storage

What Could Be Better 👎

  • Fragile wiring
  • Weak battery protection

FIALAME Swinging GhostOur pick

The serious decorator

Built with better materials, this one is actually worth the investment. It feels like a decoration rather than a toy.

What We Liked 👍

  • Durable metal construction
  • Remote control included

What Could Be Better 👎

  • More assembly required
  • Higher price point

JOYIN Hanging Ghost

Simple porch accents

It looks cute, but the reports of broken wiring are a major red flag. Keep it in a sheltered spot.

What We Liked 👍

  • Bendable arms for posing
  • Built-in timer

What Could Be Better 👎

  • Prone to wiring failure
  • Not for windy areas

CANDLE IDEA Witch HatsBest value

Creating a festive light show

These are a lot of fun and offer the best visual impact. Just be prepared to spend a little time getting them untangled.

What We Liked 👍

  • Eight different light modes
  • Fun multi-color aesthetic

What Could Be Better 👎

  • Remote can be finicky
  • Requires some assembly

Dofash Glowing Ghosts

Covering a large porch area

A solid, mid-range choice that covers a lot of ground. It is durable enough to use for more than one season.

What We Liked 👍

  • Large coverage area
  • Includes timer function

What Could Be Better 👎

  • Slightly pricey
  • Requires battery changes

Ghosts that actually stay put

If there is one thing I have learned over the years, it is that Canadian weather does not care about your Halloween spirit. Most of these hanging decorations are made of thin fabric that will look like a sad, wet rag by November 1st if you do not pick the right one.

The FIALAME swinging ghost is the only one here that feels like it was made to live outside. The others, particularly the JOYIN and BokingOne models, are essentially indoor-grade toys trying to play tough in the backyard. If you want something that will last, stop looking at the cheap plastic sets and go for the one with the metal frame.

Lighting the way to a better haunt

When it comes to lights, it is all about the modes and the timer. Nobody wants to go outside in the freezing cold every night to turn their ghosts on. The Dofash and CANDLE IDEA sets give you the best control, letting you set them and forget them. Keep in mind that none of these are going to hold up to a blizzard, so choose your display spot wisely.

Stick to the sturdy stuff

If you want something that will actually last past the first windy night, grab the FIALAME. It is the only option here that feels like it won't fall apart the moment it catches a breeze. For those of you who just want a festive, colorful look for a party and don't mind a little maintenance, the CANDLE IDEA witch hats are the most fun.

Avoid the cheaper, single-ghost options unless you are planning to hang them in a completely sheltered, indoor-protected entryway.

Prices on amazon.ca as of October 26, 2026. Prices may change.

Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.

  • Halloween
  • Outdoor decor
  • Ghosts
  • Lighting