The HEAD Xtreme Soft is the budget champion with maximum tack and sweat absorption in a soft elastomer, while HEAD Super Comp splits the difference with balanced cushioning at a modest upcharge. Wilson Pro is the premium option trusted by touring pros, offering a distinctive thin felt construction that emphasizes feel over bulk. Pick Xtreme Soft for pure grip security, Super Comp for all-around comfort, or Wilson Pro if you want that pro-level touch.
Material and tackHEAD Xtreme Soft has the most aggressive tackiness; Wilson Pro's felt offers superior feel over sheer grip power.
Super tack elastomer (winner)
Elastomer, moderate tack
High-stretch felt
Sweat absorptionBoth HEAD options explicitly absorb moisture; Wilson Pro doesn't specify sweat management in specs, though customer reviews praise its performance with sweaty hands.
Moisture-absorbing elastomer (winner)
Sweat-absorbing elastomer
Not listed
Cushioning and comfortSuper Comp hits the sweet spot; Xtreme Soft is softer but bulkier, Wilson Pro prioritizes feel and responsiveness over cushioning.
Soft, cushioned feel
Balanced, moderate cushioning (winner)
Super-thin, high-stretch
Application easeWilson Pro's tapered starting end is a pro-level design choice; both HEAD grips are straightforward once you figure out the adhesive patch.
Easy, vague instructions
Easy application
Tapered end for easy application (winner)
Price per packHEAD Xtreme Soft is the cheapest; Wilson Pro costs 50% more but offers that touring pro pedigree.
$5.99 for 3 (winner)
$6.99 for 3
$9.00 for 3
Professional endorsementWilson Pro is explicitly associated with Roger Federer and touring professionals; HEAD grips target club players.
Club-level trusted
Club-level trusted
Used by touring pros (winner)
Customer satisfactionWilson Pro edges ahead with a 4.7 rating despite fewer reviews; all three are highly rated by their user base.
4.5 stars (16,233 reviews)
4.5 stars (8,550 reviews)
4.7 stars (678 reviews) (winner)
Product by product
HEAD Xtreme Soft OvergripBest value
Budget players wanting maximum tack
The HEAD Xtreme Soft is the grip for players who sweat buckets and demand maximum hold during intense rallies. It wraps your racquet in a super-tacky elastomer that absorbs moisture like a sponge, keeping your hand glued to the handle when things get heated.
What We Liked 👍
Most aggressive tack of the three
Excellent sweat absorption
Softest, most cushioned feel
Best price point
What Could Be Better 👎
Vague application instructions
Bulkier than Wilson Pro
HEAD Super Comp Overgrip
Club players seeking balanced feel
The HEAD Super Comp is the Goldilocks of this trio: not too tacky, not too soft, just right. It delivers moderate cushioning without sacrificing the precise feedback you need for consistent shot placement, making it ideal for players who play twice a week and want a reliable all-arounder.
What We Liked 👍
Perfect balance of grip and feel
Sweat-absorbing elastomer
Moderate cushioning
Three packs for value
What Could Be Better 👎
Middle-of-the-road pricing
Less aggressive tack than Xtreme Soft
Wilson Pro Overgrip
Players prioritizing touch and feel
The Wilson Pro is the touring pro's choice, built with super-thin felt that maximizes racquet feedback and touch. If you're willing to pay a bit more and you want that crisp feel of a fresh grip without the bulk, this is your weapon of choice.
What We Liked 👍
Super-thin, high-stretch felt
Highest customer rating
Tapered starting end
Pro player endorsed
What Could Be Better 👎
Most expensive option
Sweat absorption not specified
The Material Showdown: Elastomer vs. Felt
Here's where things get interesting. The two HEAD options are built on elastomer (that rubberized, bouncy stuff), while Wilson Pro goes old school with a high-stretch felt surface. Think of it this way: elastomer is like wrapping your handle in a tacky sponge, while felt is more like wrapping it in a thin athletic sock. Both work, but they work differently.
The HEAD Xtreme Soft pushes the tack to the max with its super-tacky elastomer, making it feel like your hand is glued to the racquet. The Super Comp dials it back to 'balanced,' sacrificing some grip intensity for a softer, more cushioned ride. Wilson Pro's felt is thinner and less tacky in the traditional sense, but players rave about the superior touch and feedback it provides. If you sweat like you're training for the Olympics, HEAD Xtreme Soft is your bodyguard. If you want to feel every vibration in your racquet, Wilson Pro delivers.
The Price-to-Performance Trade-Off
At $5.99, the HEAD Xtreme Soft is the value king, and customers report being genuinely happy with it. For an extra dollar, you get the HEAD Super Comp's more balanced profile. But when you hit the $9 mark for Wilson Pro, you're paying 50% more for what's essentially a different philosophy: pro-level feel over maximum grip. That's a real choice, not just a small price bump.
Customer reviews tell the story: folks with sweaty hands and aggressive playing styles swear by the HEAD options, while players who've tried Wilson Pro often say they'll never go back because of that crisp, responsive feel. Neither is objectively 'better', it depends on whether you value maximum grip security or maximum racquet feedback. And honestly, at these price points, you could buy all three and rotate them based on conditions.
Your Grip Destiny Awaits
Here's my trail-tested take: if you're a sweaty player on a budget who wants serious grip and doesn't mind a chunkier feel, grab the HEAD Xtreme Soft. You'll get maximum tack, solid moisture absorption, and three grips for under six bucks. If you play regularly and want the comfort-to-control sweet spot without overthinking it, the HEAD Super Comp is your steady companion, it's like having a grip that just works, every time.
But if you're the type who obsesses over feel, plays competitively at least weekly, and wants that touring pro sensation, the Wilson Pro is worth the extra cash. It's thinner, more responsive, and has been the choice of elite players for decades. You're not just buying a grip; you're buying into a legacy. Whichever path you choose, you're getting a solid overgrip. The real question is whether you want maximum hold (Xtreme Soft), balanced comfort (Super Comp), or pro-level touch (Wilson Pro). Pick your adventure.
Best valueHEAD Xtreme Soft Overgrip
Prices on amazon.com as of September 18, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.
