If you want the gold standard for long-distance comfort, grab the Merrell Moab 3. For those on a tighter budget who need reliable performance without breaking the bank, the Columbia Newton Ridge or NORTIV 8 are your best bets.
WaterproofingGORE-TEX remains the king of keeping things dry, though the others work well for light splashes.
Omni-Tech membrane
RAIN.RDY (not fully waterproof)
Not listed / No
Waterproof membrane
GORE-TEX membrane (winner)
Outsole PerformanceVibram rubber is the industry benchmark for sticking to slick rock and loose dirt.
Omni-Grip
Traxion
Goodyear Rubber
Rubber / EVA
Vibram TC5+ (winner)
WeightThe Columbia model is noticeably lighter, keeping your legs fresh on long hauls.
660 Gramos (winner)
907,18 Gramos
1 Kilogramo
Not listed
Not listed
Product by product
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II
Budget-conscious style seekers
A classic suede look that performs well on moderate terrain. Perfect for weekend warriors who want reliability.
What We Liked 👍
Classic aesthetic design
Excellent value for money
Solid cushioning system
What Could Be Better 👎
Waterproofing struggles in heavy rain
adidas Terrex Anylander
Fast-paced urban and light trail
Built more like a tanky sneaker, this boot offers great grip on varied surfaces. Ideal for those who value modern styling.
What We Liked 👍
Great traction on wet terrain
Very comfortable for long days
What Could Be Better 👎
Tall fit is initially stiff
Skechers Santoro Hopkins
Comfort-first hikers
Skechers brings their memory foam expertise to the trail with a relaxed fit. Great for those who hate tight toe boxes.
What We Liked 👍
Very comfortable cushioned footbed
Goodyear rubber provides solid grip
What Could Be Better 👎
Heavier construction profile
NORTIV 8 TrekkingBest value
High-mileage budget shoppers
A workhorse boot that surprisingly handles everything from mud to snow. The ultimate value pick for tough conditions.
What We Liked 👍
Extremely durable for price
Solid ankle support provided
What Could Be Better 👎
Runs slightly large in sizing
Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTXOur pick
Serious mountain trekkers
The world's best-selling hiker for a reason, offering legendary comfort and GORE-TEX protection. It is the boot you trust with your life.
What We Liked 👍
Superior GORE-TEX water protection
Vibram sole grip is legendary
What Could Be Better 👎
Higher price bracket investment
Battle of the Boots: From Muddy Trails to Rocky Ridges
When you are miles from civilization, you do not want to worry about your feet falling apart. The Merrell Moab 3 stands as the titan here, featuring GORE-TEX and Vibram soles that make other boots look like house slippers. It is the gear you take when you are planning to spend days on your feet.
On the other end of the spectrum, the NORTIV 8 and Columbia Newton Ridge prove that you do not need to take out a second mortgage to get decent gear. They are reliable, reasonably light, and perfect for the hiker who prefers a weekend loop over a multi-week expedition.
What Actually Matters on the Trail?
It comes down to three things: comfort, grip, and moisture management. If your boots turn into sponges after an hour in the rain, your hike is doomed. The Merrell and Columbia models take the lead here. If you have wide feet, the Skechers model is a godsend for avoiding blisters.
Consider where you hike. If you are climbing sharp, volcanic rock, the Vibram soles on the Merrell are non-negotiable. If you are just strolling through forest paths, any of the others will save you a few euros while doing the job perfectly.
Choose Your Weapon
If you are a frequent trekker, the Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX is worth every cent for the durability and GORE-TEX peace of mind. It is the boot that will be at the bottom of your pack years from now.
For the casual hiker or someone watching their wallet, the Columbia Newton Ridge or NORTIV 8 will serve you brilliantly without making you compromise on basic trail performance.
Our pickMerrell Moab 3 Mid GTX
Best valueNORTIV 8 Trekking
Prices on amazon.es as of October 4, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.