Penny ParkerChocolate making kits5 products
If you want pure entertainment, go for the Buki Cook Chef for its massive variety of projects. For a simple, stress-free activity that keeps kids busy, the Choc on Choc kit is your best bet since it actually includes the chocolate.
Patient kids who love treasure
Aspiring little pastry chefs
Customizable bar enthusiasts
A quick, fuss-free activity
Serious young kitchen scientists
| Feature | John Adams Golden Coin Maker | John Adams Chocolate Lolly Maker | Oonies Chocolate Bar Maker | Choc on Choc DIY Kit | Buki Cook Chef |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | £7.65 | £8.50 | £14.99 | £14.99 | £19.90 |
| Includes ChocolateOnly the Choc on Choc kit saves you an extra supermarket trip. | No | No | No | Yes (winner) | No |
| Project VarietyBuki Cook Chef offers the most creative options by a long shot. | Coins and medals | Lollies and medals | Chocolate bars | Animal lollies | 20 recipes (winner) |
| Difficulty LevelSimple shapes make Choc on Choc much easier for younger kids. | High - requires patience | Moderate | Moderate | Low - beginner friendly (winner) | Moderate |
Patient kids who love treasure
A nostalgic kit that turns kitchen time into a pretend mint. It requires real patience and plenty of adult supervision.
Aspiring little pastry chefs
This set brings classic lolly making to the home kitchen. It is reliable but definitely needs a dedicated adult helper.
Customizable bar enthusiasts
The silicon pods make this one a bit safer for little hands to handle. It focuses on bar creation rather than shaped lollies.
A quick, fuss-free activity
The only kit that respects your time by including the chocolate. It's a premium, fun experience for a lovely afternoon.
Serious young kitchen scientists
An expansive kit that teaches actual techniques like making ganache. It's the most educational option for older kids.
If you value your sanity and your kitchen floor, listen closely. These kits are essentially high-stakes craft projects involving molten sugar and sticky fingers. The John Adams sets and the Buki Cook Chef offer the most 'pro' experience, but they demand a high level of patience from both you and your tiny trainee. If the chocolate isn't tempered perfectly or the fridge isn't cold enough, you are in for a long afternoon.
On the other hand, the Oonies Chocolate Bar Maker and the Choc on Choc kit offer a slightly more streamlined approach. Choc on Choc wins big points here simply because it doesn't leave you stranded at the kitchen counter waiting for a child to realize you forgot to buy the actual chocolate buttons beforehand.
The difference between these kits usually comes down to 'experience' versus 'result.' The Buki Cook Chef is an investment in learning; your child will actually understand how to make ganache, which is fancy for a seven-year-old. The others are more about the instant gratification of a lolly or a coin. Just remember, no matter which you pick, you are going to be scraping chocolate off your countertops for a while.
For the most variety and educational value, go with the Buki Cook Chef. It turns a standard afternoon into a full-blown culinary masterclass. If you are a busy parent who wants to be ready to go the moment the parcel arrives, Choc on Choc is the hero you need.
Pick the Buki set for a birthday gift that lasts, or the Choc on Choc set for a quiet weekend activity that won't result in a trip to the shops.
Prices on amazon.co.uk as of October 4, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.