The Redmi Note 17 Pro 5G (384 EUR) is the genuine value play: mid-range chip, but real battery endurance and a truly bright screen. The POCO F9 Pro (800 EUR) is the spec-sheet maximalist: flagship processor, 200MP camera, and wireless charging, but with marketing claims that need a fact-checker. Buy the Redmi if you want reliability at a bargain; grab the POCO if you want cutting-edge performance and don't mind the hype.
Processor PerformancePOCO F9 Pro wins decisively: flagship silicon vs mid-range means night-and-day difference in gaming, multitasking, and sustained performance.
Snapdragon 6s Gen 4 (mid-range)
Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 (flagship) (winner)
Battery Capacity & Real-World EnduranceRedmi wins on raw capacity and real-world longevity; POCO's smaller battery compensates with faster chip efficiency, but the gap favours the Redmi.
8340 mAh (2.4 days moderate use) (winner)
6330 mAh (all-day use claimed)
Charging SpeedPOCO F9 Pro wins: 100W wired and wireless charging beat the Redmi's 67W, and wireless charging alone is a major convenience factor.
67W wired + 22.5W reverse cable
100W wired + 50W wireless (winner)
Camera SystemPOCO F9 Pro wins on versatility and zoom; 200MP is marketing fluff but the telephoto lens and sensor combo offer real advantages over single 50MP setup.
50MP OIS main + AI mode
200MP + 50MP 2.5x telephoto OIS (winner)
Display Brightness & SmoothnessPOCO F9 Pro wins on smoothness; 185Hz is overkill but it delivers. Brightness claims for both are inflated, but POCO's higher refresh rate matters for gaming.
6.83" OLED, 3500 nits, 120Hz
6.59" AMOLED, 4500 nits, 185Hz (winner)
Storage & RAMPOCO F9 Pro wins: double the RAM and storage means future-proofing and never worrying about space or app multitasking.
6GB RAM + 256GB storage
12GB RAM + 512GB storage (winner)
Price-to-Performance ValueRedmi Note 17 Pro wins: half the price with a battery that actually outlasts daily life is unbeatable value; POCO costs 2x but demands flagship use cases to justify it.
384 EUR (20% discount) (winner)
800 EUR (full price)
Product by product
Redmi Note 17 Pro 5GBest value
Budget shoppers who want real battery life
The Redmi Note 17 Pro 5G is proof that you don't need a flagship chip to get a genuinely useful phone. The 8340mAh battery delivers 2.4 days of moderate use without fiction, the 50MP OIS camera handles low-light reasonably, and that 3500-nit OLED screen is bright enough to use outdoors. The Snapdragon 6s Gen 4 is the compromise, but it's honest about what it is: solid mid-range performance for everyday tasks.
What We Liked 👍
Massive 8340 mAh battery, real longevity
Bright 3500-nit OLED display outdoors
50MP OIS camera performs well
4-year warranty (3+1 years)
What Could Be Better 👎
Mid-range chip, not flagship speed
Only 6GB RAM feels tight in 2026
No wireless charging support
POCO F9 Pro
Performance enthusiasts with flagship ambitions
The POCO F9 Pro throws flagship specs at the wall like confetti: Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5, 200MP camera, 185Hz AMOLED, 100W charging. Most of it actually works and delivers real performance, but some numbers (like brightness and AnTuTu scores) need a salt shaker. Customer reviews split between 'this is incredible' and 'it throttles and feels bloated,' so the experience depends heavily on your tolerance for software bloat and thermal management quirks.
What We Liked 👍
Flagship Snapdragon 8 Elite processor
100W wired + 50W wireless charging
512GB storage means zero deletion stress
185Hz AMOLED display is smooth
What Could Be Better 👎
Thermal throttling reported in reviews
Xiaomi bloatware complaint recurring
Smaller 6330 mAh battery than rival
Spec Sheet Says One Thing, Reality Eats AAA Batteries
On paper, the POCO F9 Pro looks like it's from the future: 200MP camera, 4500-nit display, 3.8 million AnTuTu score. The Redmi Note 17 Pro plays it straighter with 50MP, 3500 nits, and a mid-range chip. Here's the thing: both are being a little creative with their marketing claims, but the POCO's claims are louder. The mysterious 'requires one AAA battery' note on the POCO listing is either a warehouse typo or a cry for help.
What actually matters is the gap between their real-world personalities. The POCO is built for people who game, edit video, and multitask heavily. The Redmi is built for people who just want their phone to live through Friday without panicking. The POCO's flagship processor is genuinely faster in apps and games; the Redmi's monster battery is genuinely more useful if you travel or forget chargers.
The Battery Paradox: Size Isn't Everything, But 8340 mAh Isn't Nothing
The Redmi Note 17 Pro has a 8340 mAh battery; the POCO F9 Pro has 6330 mAh. That's over 2000 mAh difference, roughly equivalent to an entire mid-range phone's battery. Xiaomi claims the POCO hits all-day use, but the Redmi claims 2.4 days of moderate use. Customer reviews for the POCO mention needing to charge mid-evening on heavy days, which tracks. The Redmi's bigger battery plus mid-range efficiency (less power-hungry chip) equals a phone that actually stays alive longer.
However, the POCO fights back with 100W charging, so you're back to full in about 20 minutes if you panic. The Redmi's 67W takes longer. For most people, this is the real trade-off: Do you want a phone that lasts three days, or one that charges in 20 minutes and runs hot while gaming?
Buy the Redmi If You're Tired of Charging, Buy the POCO If You're Tired of Waiting
The Redmi Note 17 Pro 5G is the no-brainer value pick: 384 EUR for a genuinely useful phone with a battery that doesn't need you to panic. It's not fast, but it works. It's not fancy, but it's honest. Four years of warranty means Xiaomi isn't ditching you next quarter. If you commute, travel, or just forget chargers exist, this is your phone.
The POCO F9 Pro is the enthusiast's gamble. At 800 EUR, you're paying for flagship performance, and you get it, but you're also getting Xiaomi's bloatware, thermal throttling complaints, and marketing slogans that belong in a Vegas casino. It's faster, smoother, and more versatile for demanding tasks. But it's also a phone that needs management and will probably feel warm in your hand during a gaming session. Buy it if you want cutting-edge performance and don't mind the trade-offs; skip it if you just want something that works without drama.
Best valueRedmi Note 17 Pro 5G
Prices on amazon.es as of September 21, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.
