Brenda MillerArtificial pumpkins5 products
If you want a cozy, high-end feel without the fuss, the Super Holiday velvet set is your best bet. For those looking for classic plastic or foam options for DIY projects or centerpieces, HAKACC offers the most complete kit for the money.
DIY enthusiasts
Minimalist decor
Rustic vibes
Classic displays
Cozy aesthetics
| Feature | HAKACC Mixed Set | BESTTOYHOME White Set | Artgar Cracked Set | Ghrdopy Colorful Set | Super Holiday Velvet Set |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $14.99 | $14.99 | $15.29 | $13.29 | $9.99 |
| Material QualityThe velvet finish on the Super Holiday pumpkins feels miles better than basic painted foam. | Polystyrene foam | Foam and plastic | Polyethylene foam | Foam | Velvet and foam (winner) |
| Quantity per SetSuper Holiday gives you the most pieces for your tabletop displays. | 14 pumpkins | 12 pumpkins | 8 pumpkins | 10 pumpkins | 15 pumpkins (winner) |
| FinishVelvet is much more forgiving and elegant than the sometimes cheap looking painted foam. | Painted speckled | Whitewashed | Metal cracked | Traditional colors | Velvet fabric (winner) |
DIY enthusiasts
A hefty set that includes maple leaves for a full centerpiece look. It is a solid choice if you want to add your own paint or glitter.
Minimalist decor
These clean, whitewashed pumpkins offer a rustic aesthetic that is easy to style. They are small, so expect to use them as bowl fillers.
Rustic vibes
The cracked metal texture adds a unique, weathered look to your fall shelf. It is a bit different from the standard smooth foam options.
Classic displays
You get the traditional orange, white, and green harvest colors here. It is a no-nonsense set for people who just want the job done.
Cozy aesthetics
The velvet finish makes these stand out from the plastic crowd. They feel much more premium and look great on a mantel or tiered tray.
Most of these sets are essentially the same lightweight foam you have seen a thousand times. If you buy the HAKACC or Ghrdopy sets, you are getting the standard craft-store variety. They do the job, but they do not exactly scream luxury. You will likely spend some time fixing the stems or ignoring the occasional dent in the foam.
The Artgar set tries to do something different with a cracked texture, which is a nice touch if you are into that weathered look. However, the real standout here is the Super Holiday velvet collection. It is the only one that actually feels like it belongs in a home rather than a kindergarten art project.
Durability is the name of the game, and unfortunately, foam is foam. If you have curious cats or rowdy kids, these things will show their age pretty quickly. The velvet ones from Super Holiday are slightly more delicate, but they look so much better that they are worth the extra care. Just keep them out of the rain, because none of these are going to survive a real storm on your porch.
If you want the best quality for your money, grab the Super Holiday velvet set. It looks significantly more expensive than it is and adds a touch of warmth that the standard foam options just cannot match. If you need a large pile of pumpkins for a craft project or to fill a giant vase, the HAKACC bundle is the way to go.
For a simple, clean, minimalist look, go with the BESTTOYHOME white pumpkins. Keep the rest of them for your specific color schemes, but do not expect them to last for a decade.
Prices on amazon.com as of September 29, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.