Jordan ClarkeStreaming media players4 products
If you want 4K performance, go for the Fire TV 4K Plus; it is the only one that feels snappy. For basic HD sets, the Roku Streaming Stick wins on interface simplicity, while the budget Fire sticks are decent if you have infinite patience for updates.
Basic HD TV upgrades
Simplicity seekers
Performance enthusiasts
Budget 4K streaming
| Feature | Fire TV Stick HD | Roku Streaming Stick | Fire TV 4K Plus | Fire TV 4K Select |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | £19.99 | £29.99 | £34.99 | £21.99 |
| ResolutionThe two 4K models clearly crush the HD sticks if your TV isn't a museum piece. | 1080p Full HD | 1080p HD | 4K Ultra HD (winner) | 4K Ultra HD |
| Interface SpeedThe Fire TV 4K Plus handles the heavy UI lifting without stuttering like its cheaper siblings. | Entry-level speed | Snappy and simple | Fastest of the bunch (winner) | Moderate performance |
| EcosystemRoku keeps it clean; the Amazon sticks are essentially glorified shopping mall billboards. | Amazon Fire TV | Roku OS (winner) | Amazon Fire TV | Amazon Fire TV |
| GamingOnly the 4K Fire models let you pretend you are a console gamer. | Not supported | Not supported | Xbox cloud gaming (winner) | Xbox cloud gaming |
Basic HD TV upgrades
A cheap way to get streaming apps on an old TV. Just prepare for a long update session.
Simplicity seekers
The interface is blissfully free of Amazon's aggressive marketing. It just works.
Performance enthusiasts
The only stick here that doesn't feel like it's struggling to keep up. It handles 4K and gaming well.
Budget 4K streaming
A middle-ground option that offers 4K, but lacks the raw speed of the Plus model.
When you look at these four, you are essentially choosing between Amazon's ecosystem and Roku's simplicity. The Fire TV sticks are all about pushing Prime Video and ad-supported content into your eyeballs, while the Roku Streaming Stick tries to stay out of your way.
Spec sheet says one thing, reality says another. While all four claim to be fast, only the Fire TV 4K Plus actually feels like it has enough processing power to handle the modern, bloated interfaces without a stutter.
If you are still rocking a 1080p TV, the Fire TV Stick HD and Roku Streaming Stick are fine. But if you have a 4K panel, do not cheap out. The 4K models provide better upscaling and, more importantly, the speed to actually navigate the menus without wanting to throw the remote through the screen.
If you want the best experience, grab the Fire TV 4K Plus. It is the only one that doesn't feel like a compromise. If you hate Amazon's UI, the Roku Streaming Stick is your only sane choice.
Prices on amazon.co.uk as of October 8, 2026. Prices may change.
Disclosure: We share affiliate links and can earn some money when you click on any of those.